Fair Cop

-
Financial Times, Friday 14 August 2020


The commotion, nay fury, surrounding the farrago that is this year's exam results for our currently maturing school student cohort is understandable in and of itself. So many results have been devalued, sometimes greatly, in stature by Ofqual and its statisticians, that the career direction and future lives of many of our young people will be altered irrevocably, mostly to their detriment and through no fault of their own.

The pretext for this 'rounding down' is that the results that stood originally fell outside the scope of the 'normal' performance curve measured historically. The outcomes on average were seen to be evidence of grade inflation. This in itself has been a criticism of results even in normal times; rising standards seen as not evidence of improvement in teaching and overall student performance, but rather as an indicator of softening of standards generally and  assessment in particular. That it is deemed by this government infeasible for improvement to happen in like manner seems curious given the general political fetish with growth and the use of crude fiscal measures such as GDP to measure the performance of the economy.

The subtext is obvious to some of us, but usually hides away in the backwaters of political discourse; but it's now rising to the surface like a particularly nasty oil slick. Todays FT carries a piece analysing this in some detail and quotes Ofqual directly. One such quotation stands out so starkly it took my breath away. I'll lift the entire paragraph directly, for anyone reading that will have missed it, and for its context:

'After moderation, the proportion of pupils achieving a C or above fell by 10.4 percentage points among the most deprived third of pupils, compared with 8.3 percentage points among the wealthiest third. Ofqual said the disparity was justified. Research showed teachers had a "tendency to over-estimate...the grades of socio-economically disadvantaged students". '(My italics)

Just think about this phrase for a few moments: "...tendency to over-estimate...the grades of socio-economically disadvantaged students". Now substitute:

"...tendency to over-estimate...the grades of Jewish students"
"...tendency to over-estimate...the grades of black students"
"...tendency to over-estimate...the grades of Muslim students"
"...tendency to over-estimate...the grades of women students"
"...tendency to over-estimate...the grades of LGBTQ+ students"

I think you get the picture. Discrimination against prejudice generally is rightly now pretty much legislated against on grounds of gender, religion and sexual orientation. But on grounds of class, we appear to be pretty much stuck in the nineteenth century. Class-ism is still normalised and even seems to be retrenching itself as the true status quo: an apposite (and deliberate) Latin cliché in itself.

It's no accident that Boris Johnson has suddenly found the time to voice an opinion '...that there had been a "robust" marking system'. This from a man who has been hiding away from the public gaze under the parliamentary recess and 'deferred paternity leave' and whose storied academic career consists in having been nannied through Prep, Eton and Oxford at extraordinary private expense; a luxury ill-afforded to those not of his class.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Of Feedback & Wobbles

-
Image
Many years ago I came up with an analogy for poorly damped feedback loops. The feedback loop that prompted this frankly tart analogy was indeed a horror. Anyone who remembers shame-faced their first attempts at clutch control resulting in the good old kangaroo launch across the lights only to stall in the middle of the crossroads will have some idea of the kind of data transfer lag involved in said system. The analogy I made was that of a large blancmange. Untouched, a model of stasis and eminently stable and predictable; but prod the bugger and the resultant chaotic behaviour needs a very complex physical model and some very decent computing horsepower to predict its outputs, if at all. The system in question was a large and complex audio-visual display at what eventually became 'The Electric Mountain' in Llanberis. We were ultimately contracted to maintain the thing having been witness to and peripherally involved in its installation. Certainly not involved in its des...
Read more

A Time of Connection

-
Image
I was just reflecting on the vacuum of continuity that's left behind when someone dies: that sudden sense of disjoint, of fracture, in one's personal history that takes one completely by surprise at the oddest moments. These pinch-points in memory can often yield some surprising revelations of fact about periods in one's past. One such occurred to me tonight, tending my rather lazy meal of pizza in its journey from shrink-wrap to mouth via the oven. Al's recent demise still catches me out from time to time: the space he left bounded by forty plus years of friendship. But the thing that struck me tonight was just how much change was happening on a personal and social level in the very early years of our acquaintance. Between moving here from Birmingham in September 1980 and our buying our first proper house eighteen months later, all manner of things occurred that would chart the course of our lives to the present day. At around the time of our meeting Alan & Irene [...
Read more

Sister Ray

-
Image
Ray Keats - aka Ann Key - local artist & family friend, died this morning. She'd been ill for some years, but never let it get in the way of her work or of tending to the massive network of friends, colleagues and fans she had accumulated over the decades. Her house on the High Street of Rachub, just below where we live - a former cockle factory(!) - bought many years ago when she and her late husband Ronald moved here from Manchester to set up home in Yr Achub, is currently still home to her paintings and drawings, and the front window displays her work, including the last drawing she made in hospital, just days before she died. Her good friend Colin has been a diamond in her latter years, looking out for her and just being there when she needed him. She will be much missed by this tiny community of ageing bohemians up here in the hills, but suffice it to say, George, her cat, will be well looked after now she's gone.
Read more